125 Columbia

Musings of the multi-faced, multi-facultied, and multi-faceted.

Wednesday, July 27, 2005

Campbell's Scoop: A slight shift in gears

Note: I realize that I stated earlier that my posts were going to be concentrated on Liverpool FC and this is true, I will talk a lot of Liverpool, but after reading Tristan’s post and of course, after the recent events in London, the kidnappings in Iraq, and the starving people of Niger I feel I am obligated to give my opinion on such matters.

Hello all,

Every time you turn on the TV, check your e-mail, hear the radio, read the paper, it is impossible to escape. It may be a different story, a different event, a different source, but it’s the same theme and topic - terrorism, hatred, poverty, and suffering. I don’t understand it, why is our world so horrible and cruel? How can we let fellow human beings starve to death while we stay in our bubbles? When I say this, let me explain that I don’t simply refer to the 1st world vs. 3rd world issues. I refer to human nature all together.

Just over the weekend, a group of friends and I were headed to a restaurant. While on the way, I noticed a scruffy looking person, almost certainly a student, sitting down on the pavement in front of a store. He looked hopeless, tired, hungry, and all the while, students walked by, running, laughing etc. It is quite possible that the person on the floor could have been a student and that those walking by, one of his peers. As my group strolled by, he didn’t even bother looking up or ask for money.

We spent about an hour and a half in the restaurant and during the meal I noticed something interesting. Some person came right up to our table and literally just asked bluntly, “do you have five dollars?” At this point, all of us at the table were shocked at the bluntness and simply said no. Afterwards, we conversed on how we hated beggers and for a brief moment, I felt nothing but pure hatred for beggers. However, when we were leaving I was very taken back by something I saw. I saw a middle aged man and his daughter kneeling down next to the student sitting on the pavement. They were just talking. I didn’t see the man give out money or anything, he just talked and I noticed them shake hands. I am not sure what was said but I’m almost certain they were words of comfort and at that point I felt very embarrassed. Here was this fellow student, sitting down on the pavement, looking very distressed and hopeless and all I did, even though I saw him, was just walk by. What harm would have come to me I had asked him if he was ok? The most would have been maybe him saying he was fine.

The reason I point out this event is to help explain to myself some questions. Why is our world so bad and cruel? Why do we hate each other so much and how can we let millions die of starvation when only a few dollars out of our pockets can make a difference? I just don’t get it.
We as fortunate individuals, place ourselves in a bubbles of ignorance and we refuse to learn and I must admit that I am one of these people. When I see something those programs on TV that exposes me to the real world, I turn it off or change the channel. I do it all the time-we all do it. Right now I feel like I’m a hypocrite. I say all these things but when it comes time for it, I don’t act. I remember feeling sick when I saw the news broadcast last night on the people in Niger,dying of starvation. But still I don’t act, why?

If you look into yourself, I’m sure that you’ve all experienced the same feeling. It seems that maybe we are just naturally cruel people? Maybe we are nothing but a violent and selfish species. Oh but isn’t that the law of nature? And that everyone looks out for themselves and its survival of the fittest? Isn’t that what all animals do? Well if you want to place yourself on the level of animals then yeah, go ahead. But humanity should be more than that. Humanity should carry with it an ideal that places us above the laws of nature and instinct. The concept of a society that has peace and equality is something that all humanity should strive for. For over 2000 years, we have been trying to establish a world for ourselves but still we are no where near the goal. But has it ever been the goal on a global scale? I don’t think so. It has always been about the success of the nation and but we fail to have that patriotic emotion for humanity as a whole. That little bit of hatred, greed, ignorance always will exist and until we learn and fully that we are all “related”, it will continue.

I am not at the level of enlightenment where I can bring sweeping changes into our world, but I feel that I must commit an individual act that will fulfill a minute fraction of the goal. Everyone, when born into our world, has rights but I feel that we also have obligations. Everyone is obligated to do their part in bringing our global society forward. The destruction of ignorance is a major factor and in the realization of the truth, we complete the first step and hopefully we will all open our eyes a little more and hopefully, act on the issue. I realize that of course, this task is enormous and obviously we can’t do everything, but a fraction from everyone will lead to the whole and by individuals understanding and accepting their role in society, our world will be a better place. Simply accepting it as it is, means you are satisfied with poverty and suffering in your life. We are at a point in time where turning the TV off is no longer an option and the global life is your life. What happens halfway around the world happens to your society as well, perhaps not on the physical level, but indeed on an ideological level.

So in conclusion, please open your eyes, listen, and realize that as individuals who have the opportunity, we can help to change our world.

Brock

Labels:

7 Comments:

- Blogger Sen

"Maybe we are nothing but a violent and selfish species. Oh but isn’t that the laws of nature? And that everyone looks out for themselves and its survival of the fittest? Isn’t that what all animals do? Well if want to place yourself on the level of animals then yeah, go ahead. But humanity should be more than that. Humanity should carry with it an ideal that places us above the laws of nature and instinct. The concept of a society that has peace and equality is something that all humanity should strive for."

Wow man that was deep - very passionate and eloquently put, straight from the heart. I really felt that youthful idealism of "Mr. Niceness" coming off the page, and I like the way you put everything in perspective.

Looking forward to more insightful posts in the future (not just Liverpool stuff!)

7/27/2005 04:54:00 PM
 

- Anonymous Anonymous

So true...

the reason i give myself, currently, for not giving money to beggers are the fact that i have no income yet. however, yeah, after reading this, i just realized i did never seriously pay attention to or empathy on them.

anyway, this does not mean we are "bad ppl". at least we are not that much aggressive as terrorists. according to wut i learnt from my social psych course, there are numerous factors determining whether or not we will apply helping behaviour. put two of them here: one is whether we interpret this is a situation somebody really needs help - the student sitting on the ground, to me, does not give any clue that he really needs our cents or dollars; the other thing is the spread of responsibility - the more observer the less chance we will help. there are a number of tragedies happened in the states is caused by our human nature.

7/27/2005 07:48:00 PM
 

- Blogger Sen

As much as I pity the poor on the street, it’s hard for me to extend any sort of empathy to them.

I think the poor on our streets suffer from a poverty of the mind more than anything else. Usually they suffer from some sort of mental illness - many are alcoholics or junkies, or street kids that fled abusive homes. Moreover they did not have stable, supportive 2-parent family upbringing that we benefited from.

Still, in a country as affluent as Canada where one can avail themselves to numerous avenues of employment (not to mention an array of social support services) there is really no reason why a perfectly able-bodied person should be begging on the street. This is Waterloo, Ontario – not Mumbai or Lagos. You can't entirely absolve them of responsibility for their condition; throwing a toonie into the hat is in a way perpetuating their misery rather than putting an end to it (and sure when I think of it that way I don't feel guilty - which is why a lot of us just walk by without a fleeting glance).

The people I have most sympathy for are the truly impoverished of the developing world who face very limited prospects for improving their condition – and yes I agree that we have an altruistic obligation to help them.

7/28/2005 11:41:00 AM
 

- Blogger Brock Campbell

I totally agree with your response to the issue of the beggers. It is true that in a country like Canada, with the abundance of social services and shelters, people have to really try to be homeless and hungry. I agree that the majority of beggers on the street are indeed substance abusers and trust me, I don't have any guilt or symphathy for them either. I don't know if you remember but in the restaurant, some guy just came and asked you for five bucks? OBVIOUSLY, that dude was pure junkie. He didn't even look that needy. The only reason I mentioned the student on the pavement was to illustrate that sometimes, when people are really down and out, people still don't help.I didn't see the man give him any money, but what I did see was him talking to the student and shaking his hand. To me certainly, this was a sign of support. It could mean a lot of things but given the location (student plaza) and appearence, I don't think he was a "junkie" begger. I will never know for sure,but the underlying point of my post wasn't just referring to beggers. My aim was to express my concern on human nature as a whole and why we don't help others on a global scale. In saying that however, I also believe that to do that, we have to start small and perhaps by helping those in need on the streets we can take our first step.

If you don't feel comfortable giving out money directly to beggers then why not donate to local foodbanks or to local charaties. The possiblities are endless yet still many people do not act.

7/28/2005 12:19:00 PM
 

- Anonymous Anonymous

I agree with you guys on this...

Most of my sympathy goes for those in the developing world too...

I don't see why we should have people dying of poverty in developing countries while we live selfish and material lives that still tend to keep us unsatisfied....and just a few dollars here and there would make a real difference in the lives of those who can't even afford food and water.

It's sad to think that despite how much money developed countries have, there is still no one reaching out with an legitimate attempt to help fellow humans....

I think with this issue, the majority of us who care still are hypocritical in aspects because it seems as though it's "hard" to really help and that we don't know what to do...

And that's what really sucks (for lack of a better word)...

7/28/2005 05:17:00 PM
 

- Blogger Sen

I don't know if you remember but in the restaurant, some guy just came and asked you for five bucks? OBVIOUSLY, that dude was pure junkie. He didn't even look that needy.

The irony is the guy who approached me for 5 bucks at East Side's happened to do so right while a job fair was taking place at the restaurant! :D

It's hard to help those that are not willing to help themselves.

7/29/2005 10:06:00 AM
 

- Blogger Tristan

this is a paradox more then anything, Poor, poverty, are a result of many factors, but the main reason is society. Due to our economic policy, which Canada and the world for this matter follows, there will always be winners (hence rich) and losers (the poor). Can we help these people? Yes we can. But its not by giving them money to fuel their addiction, Iwhy not donate to charities instead, which can help these people more? We can all agree that these beggers are MOSTLY (not all, but Most) are druggies, so if we solve that problem, then it would lead to solving other problems. Thats why, if you feel sorry for these people, (most of us do) then instead of fueling their addiction, which by giving them money hurts them even more, why not help organizations that, try to solve their addictions, and their mental anguish?

Just a thought, and not a conspircay this time =)

Two Shots

8/05/2005 12:43:00 AM
 

Post a Comment

<< Home